Guarding Stars understands the appeal of generational stars in movies and TV shows The new Netflix movie is not that good, but it shows a clear trend

Sitting at the top of Netflix’s most-watched chart is a bad romance movie, a really bad one. It’s Guarding Stars, a story built around the fake dating trope in which a bodyguard has to protect a movie star from a dangerous stalker. The gender (and genre) reversal is meant to feel modern, with the woman stepping into the protector role for the man, a narrative device that was clearly supposed to inject some comedic timing too, yet, much like the rest of the feature, fails to land the way it wants to.

Guarding Stars: plot and cast of the Netflix movie

It’s a film coated in a Hallmark-movie sheen, stitched together like a Hallmark title, and calibrated specifically for fans of Hallmark productions. It proves that Netflix hasn’t exactly been writing the new rules of the romance genre despite being one of the streamers that has bet most heavily on rom-coms in recent years. Lately, it seems to have decided that the smartest strategy is simply borrowing the playbook of a competitor whose catalog proves it knows a thing or two about Christmas movies. That, however, means bowing to bare-bones plots, flat and uninspired cinematography, and a blend of holiday cheer and sentimentality that inevitably leaves you walking away with a sweater covered in reindeer or a decorated tree. Which is precisely what happens with Guarding Stars.

Still, what stands out in the film is another trend gaining serious momentum lately, especially within the romance space. Its leads are Leighton Meester and Jared Padalecki or, as we might affectionately call them, Blair Waldorf and Sam Winchester (and if fantasy wasn’t your thing, Dean Forester works just as well). Both actors were defining faces and stars of the Millennial generation: she as the Upper East Side socialite on Gossip Girl, he as the monster hunter on Supernatural and young Rory’s first love on Gilmore Girls. Bringing together familiar faces from yesteryear makes different worlds, and fandoms, collide through a shared cultural DNA, practically guaranteeing viewers will rush to hit play, even when the movie’s actual quality is very much up for debate.

Nostalgia runs through Netflix holiday movies too, with a fresh twist

Nostalgia plays take on a fresh twist here, even if the formula has already been tested plenty of times across romance and beyond, in all sorts of variations. Just think of a franchise like The Expendables, which assembled the biggest personalities and muscles in global action cinema. What sets titles like Guarding Stars apart, though, isn’t sheer star power on its own, as in that action saga; rather, it’s everything orbiting around the leads that holds the strongest grip on our collective imagination, and therefore on audiences. Not the actors per se, but what they symbolize as icons of beloved movies and TV shows from the past. Another timely example is The 12 Dates of Christmas, a Hulu original expected to land on Disney+ soon. Set against a similarly festive backdrop, it stars Lucy Hale and Ian Harding, leads of the 2010 generational cult hit Pretty Little Liars.

Netflix calls, audiences answer

When projects like these get greenlit, the goal is clearly to capture the attention of a very specific audience right out of the gate. Netflix knows this well, and Guarding Stars is hardly the first title engineered with that purpose in mind. Albeit with a very different aura, and two legends far bigger than Meester and Padalecki, back in 2017 the platform premiered Our Souls at Night out of competition at the Venice Film Festival, reuniting Jane Fonda and Robert Redford nearly forty years after their last collaboration and a full fifty years after their romantic comedy Barefoot in the Park.

Nobody Wants This and the other shows using the exact same trick

On television, a more recent hit tapped two stars from roughly adjacent shows whose first seasons originally aired just a year apart. Straight from 2003’s The O.C. and 2004’s Veronica Mars came Adam Brody and Kristen Bell in the episodic rom-com Nobody Wants This, which debuted in 2024, now has three seasons under its belt, and pairs the two onscreen as Noah and Joanne. Brody also happens to have a direct real-life tie to Leighton Meester: the two have been married since 2014, having worked together on the 2011 film The Oranges (alongside another iconic TV lead, House’s Hugh Laurie) before starting to date in 2013. It was an opportunity Netflix couldn't pass up, even carving out a guest-starring role for Meester in season two of Nobody Wants This. And she isn’t stopping there: currently in post-production is the rom-com Adulting, which will pair her with fellow teen-TV alum Tyler Posey, straight from the Teen Wolf universe.

There is no escaping the nostalgia playbook, and the entertainment industry knows it well—which is why it will keep milking it every chance it gets. Whether across an entire movie or in brief cameos, like the recently announced crossover in the 9-1-1 TV universe reuniting Jennifer Love Hewitt and Ryan Phillippe for an episode airing in 2027, thirty years after they starred together in I Know What You Did Last Summer. It’s a way for viewers to watch beloved actors share the screen once more, and sometimes a reunion for the stars themselves, given that Love Hewitt and Phillippe admitted they hadn’t crossed paths since the theatrical release of the slasher that went on to become a cult classic.

What to read next